ME, MY GIRLFRIEND AND A BUDDY OF MINE.
So this was back from 2007-2011. Nicole and I started dating our senior year of High School when we were 18. I had never known about “cuckold” or “hotwife”, but I knew that my favorite porn at the time was MFM threesomes. Nicole was 5’4, 100lbs, with a great ass and 34Cs. We lost our virginity to each other, and she was a “good” girl when we first started dating, but boy did that change!
About a month into us dating, we were watching porn together, alternating finding videos. When it was my turn, I put on a MFM threesome video. We enjoyed it quite a bit, and I asked if she would ever like to try it someday. She was hesitant at first, saying she wouldn’t want to cheat, etc (all the standard female original objections when this topic is brought up). I reassured her that it would be okay, and after talking some more, we decided to give it a try.
Now we had been friends for years before we started dating, and ran in the same circle of friends. One of these friends, Joey, and I were very close. Growing up used to watch porn together and had jokingly even talked about sharing girlfriends when we were older and had girlfriends. I knew he was open minded, and approached him one day after school about it, and he was all for it. He was an only c***d, and had an empty house after school (both of his parents worked until at least 6pm).
So I told Nicole that Joey was interested and we set up a day after school for us all to meet there. I picked up Nicole after school (she went to a different HS), and we went to Joey’s house. She was very nervous, and asked if we could take it slow. We let her call the shots, as we were both very excited.
Nicole asked if just she and I could start, and get her “warmed up”, before Joey joined. He said sure, and excused himself to the kitchen while Nicole and I sat on the couch. After a few minutes of kissing, I slipped her shirt over her head and unhooked her bra, leaving her topless on the couch. Joey returned from the kitchen at that point, and took a seat on the loveseat across from us on the couch. Nicole was shy, and tried to cover up her breasts at first, but slowly removed her hands from her breasts and moved them to my belt, sliding off my jeans. She pulled out my cock and started stroking and sucking. Joey was playing with himself under his shorts. I asked Nicole if she was warmed up and ready, and she said not quite. She stood up and took off her pants, and laid down on the couch fully naked. I dove head first into her pussy and started sucking, licking and fingering her.
After a few minutes of this, I once again asked if she was ready, and to my surprise, she said yes. She did however say she did not want to have a threesome today, she wanted us separately for the first time (I guess she planned on this being a recurring thing!). She motioned for me to get up, and for Joey to come over to the couch. He and I traded places and he stripped down.
Now I don’t consider myself a bad lay or anything, at 6’4 with a 6 inch cock. But Joey is 6’0 and has the body of a Greek God - we jokingly call him Captain America. He too had a 6 inch cock, but he was much thicker than I was. When he stripped down, Nicole gave a gasp of approval.
He replaced me between her legs, eating her out for the first time. She and I made eye contact a lot throughout the entire event, and it was so sexy, was a very real connection and erotic experience for us. After a few minutes of him eating her out, she told him she wanted to suck him. He eagerly agreed and stood up and walked to where her head was on the couch. Laying on her back, she turned her head towards him and took the head of his cock into her mouth. His hands found their way to her breasts, and her hands worked his balls and shaft. She couldn’t quite deepthroat (yet - more on that in another post). After a few minutes of sucking, she asked if he had a condom. I tossed one to him, and he tore the packaging off and slid it on.
With her still laying on her back on the couch, he climbed between her legs and slowly entered her. She and I held eye contact the entire time, and it was just amazing to watch. The facial expressions of pure joy. They built up a nice rhythm and stayed in missionary for a few minutes. They then switched to her riding him, and it was a great view for me. From my view across from them, I had a great view of him entering her, and how wet his cock was from her - she was dripping wet and really into it I could tell. All of her reservations were gone, and she was bouncing wildly and moaning louder than I had ever heard.
After a few minutes (I do not know how he had not cum by now - I would have!), they switched to another great position for me. There was a coffee table between us, and she got into doggystyle position on the table. He, standing up, had great access to her pussy. She and I were basically face to face, and I loved it! The look on her face, seeing her big breasts swaying with his rhythm, it was breathtaking. He announced that he was close to cumming, and she leaned in and kissed me. I could feel her moans and excitement through our kiss, as he shot his load in the condom (she was on the pill, but liked to play it safe - that would change. Another story!).
After he pulled out, they both had that great “just had sex” look, and were exhausted. We all got redressed, and she leaned in to kiss him on the cheek and said thank you. She and I left, and as I drove her home, I got some great road head (she did not swallow yet - another story!)
As we were sitting in her driveway, we talked about it, and she said she really enjoyed it, and as long as I wasn’t mad about not getting the “threesome”, that she would love to try it again and make it up to me. I kissed her passionately, and said of course, we can do whatever she wants, and thanked her for giving me my fantasy.